Practical guidance for building transparent, consistent and defensible editorial workflows from submission through publication and post-publication stewardship.
Editorial Practice
Check scope, completeness, basic reporting requirements, ethical declarations, authorship information and obvious policy concerns before peer review.
Assign a suitable editor, identify conflicts of interest and document responsibility for handling the manuscript.
Select qualified reviewers, protect confidentiality, manage conflicts, track timelines and evaluate reviews for quality and professionalism.
Base decisions on the manuscript, journal criteria and reviewer evidence. Communicate clear reasons and actionable revision requirements.
Complete copyediting, metadata checks, author proofing, DOI/identifier workflows and final publication quality control.
Maintain mechanisms for corrections, complaints, appeals, expressions of concern and retractions when needed.
Set realistic editorial timelines and monitor delays without sacrificing review quality.
Apply published criteria fairly across authors, institutions and subject areas.
Maintain an auditable record of decisions, conflicts, communications and policy actions.
Receive updates on training, conferences, editorial resources, opportunities and scholarly publishing developments.