Guidance for editors on designing reliable review processes, selecting reviewers, protecting confidentiality and making evidence-informed editorial decisions.
Editorial Practice
Peer review should improve scholarly quality while treating authors and reviewers fairly. Journals should explain their model, expectations, confidentiality rules and decision process.
Reviewers know author identities while reviewer identities are not disclosed to authors. Editors should actively manage bias and conflicts.
Author and reviewer identities are concealed where practicable. Journals need clear anonymisation instructions and should acknowledge that complete anonymity cannot always be guaranteed.
One or more identities or reports may be disclosed. The exact level of openness and consent arrangements should be stated before review.
Confidentiality: Manuscripts and unpublished findings must not be shared or used improperly.
Objectivity: Critique the work, not the authors. Comments should be specific, respectful and evidence-based.
Conflicts: Reviewers should disclose relationships or interests that could compromise impartiality.
Timeliness: Accept reviews only when the expertise and time needed for a useful report are available.
Check scope, minimum quality, ethical requirements and basic reporting before external review.
Invite appropriate reviewers and provide structured guidance aligned with the journal's criteria.
Editors should evaluate reviewer reasoning rather than simply count recommendations. Conflicting reviews may require further assessment.
Communicate the decision, essential revisions and relevant reviewer comments without contradictory or inappropriate instructions.
Editors should intervene when reports contain:
Inappropriate comments may be removed or a review may be disregarded, with the action documented.
Journals can recognise high-quality reviewing through acknowledgements, certificates, reviewer records or other appropriate mechanisms while preserving the confidentiality promised by the journal's review model.
Receive updates on training, conferences, editorial resources, opportunities and scholarly publishing developments.